Win percentage: 74.0741%
Matches on record: 108
Whilst many will remember Big Poppa Pump’s ill-fated WWE run of 2002-04, Steiner had previously built up the bulk of his WWE wins 10 years earlier, whilst still teaming with his brother Rick. In that time, both Rick and Scott racked up a 91.0714% win average, which would have given Rick the #2 spot on this list, had we capped the matches at 50, rather than 100.
Scott’s flatulent singles run in 02-04 however, saw his average plummet over a further 50 matches.